With a card, you can buy a "mag reader" which can download and store the magentic strip on the card so you can reprogram it to anothe rcard later. The difficult thing to catch about this is that the theive can reprogram one of his own personal cards that will match his ID when he uses it. The 18 year old teller behind the cashier will go through his / her usual procedure of checking the ID and name and run it through. The teller would have to had checked the last 4 numbers on the card used to the last 4 numbers that print on the receipt, 100percent of the time when they dont match, stolen card. I recommend you are present when ever they run any card that is under you or your companies name, put fraud alerts on all your accounts so when a transaction tries to hit yoru account, it must be verbally cleared through with the credit cart company.
Now as far as checks go, DONT EVER USE CHECKS!! common, your pretty much giving a theive your routing number, account number, and series number for checks, whats to keep someone with a computer and printer from going to an office supply store to buy blank payroll checks and put your accounting info on them with their name ?
Sorry to hear what happened. unfortunatly our current laws have not caught up with todays crime and the punishment and jail time for this type of offense would get a first offender a slap on the hand.